Signed in as:
filler@godaddy.com
By JAMIE WACHTER on Wednesday, November 11, 2026
BOCC race recount avoids tiebreaker, barely.
Suwannee County Commission District 2 candidates Stefan Blue (left) and Shea Deloach watch as ballots are fed through a machine at the Suwannee County Supervisor of Elections Office on Tuesday during the recount of their race, which ended with Deloach defeating Blue by one vote. (JAMIE WACHTER/Lake City Reporter)The board game was already purchased.
But there was no rolling of the dice needed to break a tie in the Suwannee County Commission District 2 race after all.
While the machine recount and a literal hand count of 747 early voting ballots during the recount Tuesday at the Suwannee County Supervisor of Elections Office had Shea DeLoach and Stefan Blue knotted, a reexamination of all the early voting ballots cast over eight days found the deciding vote. It went to DeLoach.
“I’m just glad the process is over, it’s been tough,” DeLoach said, crediting Blue for running a clean campaign. “It’s been hand-in-hand (the whole race).
“I’m just glad it’s over.”
That review of the eight envelopes — one day’s worth of early votes in each — which had already been sorted to find Precincts 1 and 8, the two that voted for the county commission race, settled the race after both the machine recount and hand count had turned up one fewer vote than the Election Night totals.
It also meant DeLoach had 876 votes to Blue’s 875.
“I’m really glad it’s over, wish it would have been a different outcome but I understand it is an election,” Blue said. “We understand how important voting is now. I just encourage everybody to vote because it is very important that you do vote.
“Congratulations to Mr. DeLoach for winning, for running a good race. I wish him the best.”
Had that ballot not been located, the 26 under votes that existed in the race were all determined to be true under votes with neither DeLoach nor Blue circled in, the election would have ended in a tie.
Florida Statute 100.181 calls for those ties to be broken by a “drawing of lots,” as County Judge Jennifer Griffin read out to the two candidates and approximately 12 other observers in the room along with the rest of the canvassing board and elections staff.
That could have been a coin flip. Or drawing straws. Or cutting a deck of cards with the higher number winning. Griffin had found those options used previously.
County Attorney Adam Morrison, among the observers in the room, suggested purchasing a Monopoly game and rolling the dice. One candidate would be odds, the other evens. A winner would be decided.
The candidates agreed.
“I was looking forward to rolling the dice,” Blue said. “Kudos to (Supervisor of Elections) Jennifer (Kinsey)’s office, I thought they did a wonderful job. Those of us were here for the process, we see how the process works. I think it worked very well.”
Still, DeLoach was thankful that it didn’t come down to that “game of chance.”
“A tiebreaker, rolling dice, I’m not a gambling man,” he said. “I’m not a gambler. I don’t know about the dice stuff.”
Instead, after Morrison left to purchase the game, the early voting envelopes turned up the deciding ballot at around 2:30 p.m., more than four hours after the recount began with a logic and accuracy test ran on all the voting machines used during the election. That test showed the machines all were accurate.
Nearly two hours later, the 1,750 ballots were all ran back through the machines and recounted.
That vote came up with the tie of 875 votes apiece, but one fewer vote than on Election Day after a vote-by-mail ballot had been cured when the voter came in and signed for it.
At that point, around 1 p.m., the two candidates agreed to the election staff manually counting the early voting ballots, where the discrepancy was in the number of ballots from Election Day totals and the recount totals. That decision also followed Kinsey seeking guidance from Joel Foreman, the office’s attorney.
That manual recount, after four staff members each counted them, came up the same: the momentary tie.
“That’s the good thing about it, you get to choose who you vote for, whether to vote or not vote, we always encourage everybody to vote,” Blue added. “That’s what makes democracy work.”

DISTRICT 2 CANDIDATE
Today, I am proud to announce my candidacy for Suwannee County Board of County Commissioners, District 2. As a lifelong resident of Suwannee County, I have dedicated my career to public service, and I am committed to working with our community to ensure a strong responsible, and united future for our county.
I am a 1983
DISTRICT 2 CANDIDATE
Today, I am proud to announce my candidacy for Suwannee County Board of County Commissioners, District 2. As a lifelong resident of Suwannee County, I have dedicated my career to public service, and I am committed to working with our community to ensure a strong responsible, and united future for our county.
I am a 1983 graduate of Suwannee County High School, a U.S. Army Veteran, and an attendee of Florida Gateway Community College. For more than 30 years, I served in public safety-retiring as a Law Enforcement Captain with the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, where I protected, secured, and defended the State of Florida's multi billion dollar agricultural industry, and was responsible for safeguarding consumers from fraud under Florida law and department's regulatory authority. My wife, Palizzia "Lise" Blue and I have raised our three children-Emaze, Emyrick, and Emaysa-here in Suwannee County, and our roots in the community run deep.
My experience working with federal, state, and local government agencies has prepared me to serve effectively as a county commissioner. I understand the responsibility of government to operate effectively, transparently, and with accountability to the people. Maintaining the public's trust is essential, and I am committed to ensuring that /suwannee County's government reflects the values and priorities of it's citizens.
For 15 years, I have served on Suwannee County Development Authority and currently serve as CoChairperson, supporting smart growth and economic development that improve quality of life for our residents. In 2012 I was honored to serve as CoChairperson of the City of Live Oak Review Board, representing my district and helping strengthen the foundation of our local government.
My service also extends deeply into our schools and community organizations. I have served as a Panel Member on Suwannee County District Educational Hour, helping inform and engage the public on key educational topics affecting our students and families. I am a Substitute Teacher, and Advisory Member for Suwannee County School District, and also belong to the Suwannee County Voters League. Additional I serve as CoChairperson of the Trustee Board at Sweet Hope Missionary Church and have been involved with the African American Development Council, Inc., contributing to initiatives that uplift and support our community.
In 2017, I was recognized by Florida Public Safety Institute for my contributions to public service as part of the Recognizing the Role of African Americans Shaping Florida Today initiative, and was featured in a Fresh From Florida publication for my efforts in recruiting career professionals. In 2025, the Suwannee High School Girls Weightlifting Team Leadership Award was renamed in honor of my family's legacy of leadership, integrity, and community impact-an acknowledgment that deeply humbles me and strengthens my commitment to serve others.
I value fiscal responsibility and support public projects that enhance essential services as our county continues to grow. My Lifelong dedication to service, leadership, and community engagement has prepared me to step forward in a new capacity. I am running for County Commissioner because I believe in Suwannee County-it's people it's potential, and it's future.Ilook forward to earning your support and working together to strengthen our community for generations to come.

DISTRICT 2 CANDIDATE
My name is Walter "Shea" DeLoach and I am asking for your support as your next Suwannee County Commissioner for District 2. I am a lifelong Suwannee County resident, farm raised, and proud graduate of Suwannee High School. This community has shaped who I am, and belive it is important to give back by serving the people
DISTRICT 2 CANDIDATE
My name is Walter "Shea" DeLoach and I am asking for your support as your next Suwannee County Commissioner for District 2. I am a lifelong Suwannee County resident, farm raised, and proud graduate of Suwannee High School. This community has shaped who I am, and belive it is important to give back by serving the people who have given me so much.
As a husband, father, and lifelong resident, I understand the values that make Suwannee County a special place to live, work, and raise a family. My children have attended our schools, and I have spent my career working for the State of Florida, in private business, and as a self-employed businessman. These experiences have taught me the importance of responsibility, hard work, and making smart financial decisions.
If elected, my priorities will be improving our roads and infrastructure, addressing traffic concerns, supporting agriculture, and ensuring taxpayer dollars are spent wisely. As someone who was raised on a farm, I know agriculture is not just part of our history-it remains a vital part of our economy and our future. I will work to protect and strengthen our agriculture community while encouraging responsible growth that benefits everyone.I belive county government should be transparent, accountable, and focused on serving its citizens. I will listen to your concerns, make decisions based on common sense, and always put the interest of Suwannee County first.
I am not running for this office to build a political career. I am running because I love this community and want to help preserve the values that made Suwannee County a wonderful place to call home. I would be honored to earn your trust and your vote for Suwannee County Commissioner, District 2.